When deciding to build a website, one of the first and most important decisions you’ll face as a business owner is choosing the right platform. With so many options available that each claim to be the best, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Do you go with WordPress, the powerhouse behind over 40% of all websites, or opt for a hosted platform like Shopify, Wix, BigCommerce, Squarespace, or other similar platforms?
While a hosted website with drag and drop page builders offer an all-in-one solution with quick setup, WordPress provides a level of flexibility, customization, and long-term scalability that most growing businesses often need. If you’re looking to build a website that grows with your business and has no limits, our opinion is that WordPress is the clear winner.
Let’s break down why.
Hosted website builders like Shopify and Squarespace are designed for simplicity. They provide a fully managed experience, meaning hosting, security, and updates are handled for you. Their biggest appeal is ease of use—many offer drag-and-drop design tools and pre-built templates that make website creation fast and beginner-friendly.
However, the convenience comes at a cost. These platforms come with limitations on customization, ownership, and long-term scalability. You are locked into their ecosystem, meaning you can’t take your website with you if you ever want to switch platforms. You are also limited by their pre-set design options, third-party app costs, and ongoing monthly fees.
Client Case Study: Guild Solutions Group came to us after struggling with a hosted website platform that limited their growth. As leaders in the breaching and CQB industry, they needed a site that could scale with their expanding business, not one that restricted their capabilities. Their previous platform locked them into pre-set design options, lacked flexibility, and didn’t provide the control they needed to showcase their specialized services.
We built a fully custom WordPress website that gives them unlimited scalability, full ownership, and the ability to evolve without restrictions. With their new site, Guild Solutions Group can expand their content, integrate new features, and maintain complete creative control—without worrying about outgrowing the platform.
Their experience highlights the key trade-offs between convenience and long-term potential. While hosted website builders like Shopify and Squarespace offer quick solutions, they come with limitations that can hinder growth, customization, and ownership. By switching to WordPress, Guild Solutions Group now has a future-proof website built to grow alongside their business, with no barriers in sight.
WordPress, on the other hand, is an open-source platform, meaning you have full control over your website’s design, functionality, and future growth. Whether you need a simple business website, an e-commerce store, a membership platform, or a content-driven blog, WordPress can handle it all, without limiting your growth.
Unlike hosted solutions, WordPress gives you true ownership of your site, allowing you to customize every detail, choose your own hosting, and integrate with thousands of trusted plugins and tools. The trade-off? It requires more setup and maintenance. However, with the right expertise (or a WordPress maintenance plan provided by Cardinal South Creative), you can enjoy all the benefits without the hassle, but we’ll get to that later.
Unlike Shopify or Squarespace, which limit how much you can customize your website, WordPress lets you control every aspect of your design. Using tools like Elementor and Crocoblock, we can build you a fully custom website that perfectly reflects your brand and doesn’t lock you in with cookie-cutter templates.
Beyond aesthetics, WordPress allows full customization of functionality. Whether it’s a unique navigation structure, interactive elements, or a fully custom checkout experience, WordPress gives you the power to create exactly what you need without limitations.
Many businesses start with a hosted platform because it seems simple, and that makes sense at first. But as they grow, they often hit a wall. Whether it’s needing advanced e-commerce functionality, integrating a membership site, or improving SEO, they find themselves reaching that limitation. What happens after that? Businesses outgrow them because of their fixed-features and often face expensive migrations later on. We don’t want that happening to you!
WordPress eliminates those barriers. It can grow and evolve with your business, whether that means adding new service pages, launching an online store with WooCommerce, integrating advanced lead generation tools, or even scaling to a full-fledged enterprise website. Since there are no built-in platform restrictions, you have the freedom to expand whenever you’re ready. You wouldn’t want to limit your growth from day one, and we don’t want you to either!
If search engine rankings matter to your business, WordPress is the best choice. It gives you complete control over your SEO strategy, allowing you to optimize every detail. This includes page URLs, metadata, structured data, and performance speed. Advanced SEO plugins like Yoast SEO and Rank Math provide additional tools to fine-tune your website for better search visibility.
Hosted platforms like Shopify and Wix have SEO limitations that can restrict your ability to optimize your site fully. Many business owners don’t realize these limitations until they start struggling to rank on Google and find themselves unable to make necessary technical adjustments.
WordPress also allows for performance optimizations that hosted platforms do not. You can customize caching, image compression, and mobile responsiveness to ensure your site runs as efficiently as possible.
One of the biggest downsides of Shopify, Wix, and Squarespace is that you don’t actually own your website. Instead, you’re simply renting space on their platform. If you ever decide to switch, moving your website content can be difficult, if not impossible (and very expensive). You are also bound by their pricing structures, which means you will always be paying monthly fees just to keep your site live.
With WordPress, you have full ownership of your website files, database, and hosting. You can switch hosting providers, redesign your site, or even migrate to a different content management system without losing your data or being locked into costly subscriptions.
At first glance, platforms like Shopify or Squarespace may seem like more affordable options, but over time, their costs add up. These platforms charge monthly subscription fees and, in some cases, additional transaction fees on every sale. As your business grows, the costs of using a hosted platform can significantly outweigh the convenience. This can be worth it for some, but it doesn’t always add up to a great deal.
With WordPress, there are no mandatory monthly fees beyond your chosen hosting plan and any optional premium plugins. Many businesses find that WordPress offers far greater value in the long run while allowing them to build exactly what they need without additional hidden costs.
One of the biggest reasons businesses hesitate to use WordPress is because it requires ongoing maintenance. Unlike Shopify or Wix, which handle hosting, security, and updates for you, WordPress requires someone to monitor security, update plugins, optimize performance, and manage backups.
That’s where Cardinal South Creative comes in...
With our WordPress maintenance plans, we take care of all the technical work so you don’t have to. We ensure that your site is always updated, secure, and running smoothly. We handle security monitoring, plugin updates, backups, and optimizations so you can focus on running your business instead of worrying about website management. Businesses are hard enough to run, we don’t want your website to be another burden. We want you to focus on what matters most, your customers!
With one of our WordPress maintenance plans, you get all the flexibility and power of WordPress, without the hassle of maintaining it yourself.
The decision ultimately depends on your business needs, but if you want a website that offers full control, scalability, and long-term growth potential, WordPress is the best investment.
If you simply need a quick, easy-to-manage website and don’t require advanced features or long-term scalability, a hosted platform like Shopify or Squarespace may work. However, keep in mind that as your business grows, hosted platforms can become limiting, expensive, and difficult to migrate away from. Although we would love to have your business, we’d rather have it at the beginning, rather than down the road after you’ve invested so much in another platform.
For businesses that are looking for complete customization, control over SEO, and the ability to expand without restrictions, WordPress is the clear winner.
If you need a website that works for your business now and in the future, WordPress is the best option. It allows you to customize, scale, and own your website without being tied to a third-party platform’s rules. While it does require some technical upkeep, our WordPress expertise and maintenance plans ensure that you never have to worry about the backend.
Need help deciding what’s best for your business? Let’s talk about your goals and find the right solution for you!
Ready to bring your vision to life? Click ‘GET STARTED’ to begin your journey with us. Let’s create something amazing together!
